Friday, 10 May 2013

No new FIFA members for the Caribbean yet

The five new members of CONCACAF are highly unlikely to be fast-tracked into FIFA membership at the world body's next Congress later this month in Mauritius.

Although South Sudan joined both the Confederation of African Football and FIFA inside six months last year, FIFA does not expect to welcome in Guadeloupe (pictured below at the 2012 Coupe de l'Outre Mer), Martinique, French Guiana and Saint Martin, or the Dutch island of Sint Maarten.


A FIFA spokesperson said: “The admittance of the 5 member associations to CONCACAF (Martinique, Guadeloupe, French Guiana, St Martin & St Maarten) does not imply automatic or direct membership to FIFA. Any association seeking affiliation to FIFA must observe FIFA’s regulations related to the subject.

“The admission of football associations to FIFA is referred to in many provisions of the FIFA Statutes and in specific regulations. In particular, art. 10 par. 1 of the FIFA Statutes stipulates that: 

"Any Association which is responsible for organising and supervising football in its country may become a Member of FIFA. In this context, the expression “country” shall refer to an independent state recognised by the international community. Furthermore, and as contemplated in such article, any candidate must have reached a good level of development in terms of championships, infrastructures, etc.”

Although Guadeloupe, Martinique and French Guiana have well developed leagues, the infrastructure is less developed in Saint Martin and Sint Maarten, the Dutch controlled side of the same island.


There have been some suggestions that all five islands had the support of either the French or Dutch national associations, but this is also not the case, certainly for Sint Maarten.

Saint Martin is unable to take part in the biennial Coupe de l'Outre Mer for French overseas territories or departments because the island's association was simply too slow in contacting the French federation, the FFF, after the first competition was staged in 2008. 

Instead, the tiny North American territory of St Pierre et Miquelon took the last remaining place of what is now an eight team competition, but St Pierre will not join Concacaf because traveling to matches is both lengthy and very expensive for an association with just three clubs.

Sint Maarten do not take part in the annual ABCS for Dutch-speaking teams in the Caribbean and are unlikely to either.

“The ABCS Cup is all about Aruba, Bonaire, Curacao and Suriname,” says Kenneth Jaliens, the manager of Suriname. “That’s why the name is ABCS.”

Surinam are not even in touch with the fledgling association on Sint Maarten. Jaliens says the Surinaamse Voetbal Bond relies on the Dutch FA for contact but the KNVB is not in touch with the Sint Maarten association.

The KNVB is working with FIFA to develop pitches at Antriol and Rincon and a mini-pitch at North Salina on Bonaire, another Dutch-controlled Caribbean island that was welcomed as an associate member of Concacaf recently and does play in the ABCS Cup, but there has been no contact whatsoever with Sint Maarten.

Johan van Geijn, international co-ordinator at the KNVB, says: “We currently have no contacts with St Maarten FA and we don’t know who’s in charge. Our last interventions were a few years ago and focused on youth.

“We do not facilitate the islands with finances. We facilitate courses and for Bonaire we have done something special with our Goal project: two new artificial fields and an artificial mini-field.”

Quite why Sint Maarten have been allowed into Concacaf is hard to gauge; certainly the other Dutch islands have no idea and the move looks increasingly like an attempt to bolster numbers ahead of a bid for more World Cup finals’ places – just the sort of ploy that Jack Warner employed in the 1990s.

Thursday, 2 May 2013

Inconsistent membership rules frustrate Gibraltar


This story appeared earlier at wsc.co.uk
Four French overseas territories and the Dutch territory of Sint Maarten were promoted to full membership of Concacaf at the federation's recent congress in Panama on April 19. Although there are some good footballing reasons for this to have happened, it also looks like double standards. Guadeloupe have regularly qualified for the regional Gold Cup tournament and even reached the semi-finals in 2007, beating Canada and Honduras on the way.

Martinique (pictured above at the 2012 Coupe de l'Outre Mer in Paris) will feature at this summer's Gold Cup after a team featuring West Ham reject Frédéric Piquionne qualified via a fourth-place finish at the 2012 Caribbean Cup; French Guyana have also managed to qualify for the Caribbean Cup finals.

However, footballing activity in the fourth French territory, Saint Martin, is more sporadic. A team was entered into the Caribbean Cup qualifiers but lost all three games and conceded 24 goals without scoring. Saint Martin shares an island with the Dutch territory of Sint Maarten, who did not even bother entering the Caribbean Cup. In 2010 FIFA visited Sint Maarten as part of a working party on new members, led by English vice-president Geoff Thompson. The next year, a Dutch FA source admitted the football set-up there was a "mess" yet the territory is now a full Concacaf member.

That should not really be a surprise, as the Turks & Caicos Islands were admitted into Concacaf in the 1990s when there was not even a functioning football association on the British overseas territory. In 1998, the newly formed TCIFA was admitted into FIFA and has since received millions of dollars in aid.

All this will stick in the craw of the Gibraltar Football Association (GFA), which was formed in 1895 and has been trying to join UEFA since 1999. After years of filibustering, this tiresome process reaches an end-game at UEFA's congress at Wembley on May 24. After Gibraltar originally applied, Spain protested and UEFA switched its membership criteria: all new members must now be in the United Nations. The Court of Arbitration for Sport has since ruled three times that as this switch was made after Gibraltar applied this was simply not on.

A previous vote on Gibraltar at a UEFA congress in Frankfurt attracted just three votes: Scotland, Wales and the Republic of Ireland. Even the English did not support the Rock's footballers, but this time should be different. In October 2012, Gibraltar were admitted as a provisional UEFA member. Since then the GFA have trekked across Europe on a very professional lobbying campaign to put forward a footballing case rather than a political one.

A 3-0 win over the Faroe Islands in 2011 and a 7-5 victory over San Marino in a UEFA futsal qualifier earlier this year helped. Gibraltar are not Europe's worst team and are hopeful of victory at Wembley. Should they be foiled again, the Gibraltarians will surely look at the outcome of that Concacaf congress in Panama City and feel doubly wronged.

Wednesday, 10 April 2013

Outcasts talk




For anyone interested in Outcasts and within reach of London, I will be giving a talk on the background to the forthcoming vote on Gibraltar's UEFA membership application as part of the Sport Business Centre Seminar Series at Birkbeck College on April 18.

The seminar also cover how other overseas dependencies are treated in international football and the problems facing other aspiring FIFA members from Kosovo to Kiribati, including areas covered in the epilogue of the new Kindle edition of Outcasts, which was published before Christmas.

The seminar starts at 6:00pm and entrance is free. For further details go to the Birkbeck Sport Business Centre website.